About ME/CFS–The Illness of Disappearing

Gorgeous cloud-dusted sky over scrubby ground and shrubs, red rock formations, and snow-peaked mountains in Colorado–on a day my family was hiking while I rested at home. 

This piece isn’t about children’s books. It explains why I’ve missed most aspects of the children’s literature world since 2019–the month my first book The Amazing Idea of You (Lundquist, Bloomsbury) launched. Despite my determination and love of books, my care for children, my publications remain few. I have an illness that often renders people invisible. It has not been easy for me to talk about it publicly. The ongoing grief of missing so much life is vivid; I worry anything I say will feel like a wail. And there is much I am thankful for, too. But I want to start talking about this experience more.

Right now, I’m needing to reach out to my local community for more support, so I wrote this originally for them, and for those who have asked what ME/CFS is. And for anyone who knows someone with a complex illness or who has one. I’m not a medical professional. This is simply my best understanding of ME/CFS after having to become my own doctor, since 95% of my providers don’t know anything about it.

Learn more here: CDC, #MEAction, Bateman Horne Center, ME/CFS Clinic MN

 

ABOUT ME/CFS–FOR THOSE WHO HAVE ASKED

My first nine doctors didn’t know what I had when I suddenly became so weak that standing was work. Yet the medical world has known about ME/CFS illness for a long time. Perhaps because it disproportionately affects women, it has long been ignored, denied research funding, and stigmatized. People applying for disability often focus on other illnesses to win their cases. I had one doctor say it was in my head without running tests. One focused an appointment (which made me very ill to attend) on proving I didn’t have ME/CFS, while ignoring my symptoms and not helping me cope. Had I known what I had immediately, I might have recovered in that first year.

ME/CFS is a multi-system illness triggered by a stressor (virus, infection, accident, emotional trauma, mold, anemia, hormone changes, etc.). After this, the body fails to return to normal; it gets “stuck” in disfunction. There is no cure and only 5% of people recover fully. The best chance of recovery is in the first 6-12 months, with extreme rest. But many medical providers still suggest Graded Exercise Treatment (GET), despite consistent evidence that this is the fastest way to become permanently worse. I fell into this trap on my own.

I likely had 2 brushes with “mild” ME/CFS at ages 10 and 31, from which I recovered. I don’t know the original trigger (mold, virus, stress?), but my permanent ME/CFS followed multiple stresses: perimenopause, 4 years of isolation from leaving MN, 2 spouse deployments, undiagnosed fibroids/ anemia, and insomnia (from hormones and dysautonomia.) I had general decline in my early 40s that sped up in 2018.

On Jan. 14, 2019, age 44 (3 weeks before my debut book launch), I tried to exercise until I felt “funny.” I stopped to video chat with Tara. Within minutes, I was so weak I could hardly speak. I worried it was a stroke. From Turkey, she arranged a ride to the doctor. Just before our move to Italy, I traveled to MN and was “lucky” that my 10th doctor recognized ME/CFS in July—that’s VERY fast. But it wasn’t fast enough. I didn’t understand the danger of exercise. After arriving in Italy in August, I took long walks to try to regulate my sleep after jet lag. Within two weeks, I’d become severe—mostly lying down, unable to leave home.

Photo by C. S. Wild 2021 - Nighttime window with a reflection/ silhouette of a figure with hair in a loose bun, lamp and dressers from a living room, looking out on fading sunset, silhouette of trees and a barn. The moon looks like a small jewel or tear on the figure's face.

Photo by C. S. Wild 2021, Sacile, Italy – Nighttime window with a reflection/ silhouette of a figure with hair in a loose bun, lamp and dressers from a living room, looking out on fading sunset, silhouette of trees and a barn. The moon looks like a small jewel or tear on the figure’s face.

 

What does ME/CFS “do”?

– The aerobic energy system breaks, sometimes the anaerobic system

– The body can’t recover from activity/ stress—physical, mental, emotional, or sensory (heat, smells, noise, etc.). Once something triggers exertion (reading too long, insomnia, an argument, getting hot, prepping food, laughing at a movie), the chain reaction of symptoms starts and the body doesn’t recover normally, sometimes for days, months or years.

– Research suggests that ME/CFS involves:

neuro-inflammation

inflammation

immune disfunction

blood flow problems

oxidative stress (lack of oxygen in cells/ brain)

poor autophagy (body doesn’t clean up dead cells)

disrupted glymphatic system (e.g. lymph and toxins back up in the brain)

hormone disruption

body systems stop communicating effectively

 

Most people with ME/CFS also have some type(s) of dysautonomia: disruption of systems that control autonomic functions, such as digestion, circulation, temperature regulation, rest and stress responses, etc. This can lead to many problems: GI issues, fainting, headaches, sweating or not sweating, insomnia, being stuck in “fight or flight,” extreme fatigue, brain fog and more. Dysautonomia doesn’t have a cure, but can be improved via lifestyle and medications. Treating and managing this has helped me significantly.

 

ME/CFS is distinguished from other illnesses by Post Exertional Malaise (PEM). Any stress or activity beyond one’s limits (which are low) triggers a chain reaction of worsened symptoms, often after a delay of 2-5-days. A week after a big exertion, I’m usually not recovered but just hitting my worst symptoms. Sometimes I feel *better* the day(s) after overexertion (riding that stress hormone wave, baby). Trouble hits later. After getting COVID in 2022, I felt amazingly well for a week. Then…I experienced the worst two years of my illness to date. I couldn’t make a 5-minute phone call without symptoms for days. PEM is tricky with that delay. And the illness in general can be very isolating. For me, loneliness is the worst part.

ME/CFS is very individual and also dynamic–always changing. What I can safely do at night could wreck me in the morning. Winter and summer are worse. New medications, supplements or treatments change my body’s “rules,” especially at first. My ability is never the same two days in a row—which makes pacing utterly confusing, even with a monitoring device (Visible app) to help track my exertion. Even when I CAN do something once, I need to protect myself against getting worse. Triggering major PEM runs the risk of lowering one’s baseline long-term. Life with ME/CFS is about constant restraint.

 

Even so, PEM can’t always be avoided. You need that medical appointment. Sometimes, I overdo it making the bed. Showering means 1 night of insomnia, 2 days of recovery—but eventually you have to bathe. Sometimes, I choose PEM in order to talk to loved ones. What is life without connection? So, everything is about choosing how to spend the tiny bit of ability you have in a day. And choosing wisely ise harder when wired-tired or groggy-foggy.

August 2025, in a school hallway. I’m in a red electric chair, in a floral dress, with my head thrown back in laughter, between two smiling/ talking friends, whom I’d just seen in a play. This was my first public event in seven years. So happy!

 

What is PEM like? It depends on the person and the moment.

I’m lucky. Some people have much more acute symptoms. Mine range from annoying to overwhelming. Most symptoms are hard to describe. When overextended, my cells feel like they straining and hurting as I move. I might feel like I am in overdrive, skin burning, body shaky, sleep and clear thinking elusive–I might write endless rambling words while wired-tired. Sometimes I feel trapped, drowning in a sea of heavy fatigue and fog. I can’t read, think, communicate easily. I feel like I’m talking to my wife through 3 feet of fogged glass, trying to focus my thoughts, which hurts with the strain. Someone online said it can feel like being filled with angry bees inside. Fatigue can hurt, feel urgent, like an emergency. Sometimes I feel totally fine. Especially when I spend most of my day lying and calm, I feel normal, peaceful, and joyful. As long as I don’t do anything.

But when in certain stages of a “crash” my emotions become dysregulated. I feel extreme despair, like PMS x 50. This usually comes with the kind of fog when I can’t distract myself with reading or writing. This is my hardest symptom (except for rare migraines)

 

What is my ability like? Depends…

I’m still mostly at home. I generally don’t drive. Texting and fine motor movements are harder. The last few years, I’ve only finished 3-4 long-form books a year (this one is sad). At my worst in Italy, I went 3 years without talking to a friend live or face-to-face, except for 2 or 3 very short phone calls. That level of loneliness is unbearable. Now, with more symptoms better managed, I generally feel better than those years—though it depends. I’m freer to sit up (reclined) and move around the house. I talk more! I had a few amazing weeks in June 2026 when I started leaving the house and going to family/ friend events. I helped arrange our new MN home. But then I crashed hard for 2-3 months.

Our ginger doggos on a moving blanket, on a chair by the window–Bravo, a mini bernedoodle looking out, Lucy the Righteous Chiweenie looking dignified.

I don’t really understand my life. Or its direction. It has little shape beyond the energy patterns of a day and season. Grief wanders through my rooms. In the early years, I felt like a ghost, surrounded by the artifacts of my Before Life. Also, there are still moments of connection, when the kids in our family process their lives and wonderings. There’s a precious talk with a friend who survived cancer. Music that makes the hair on my arms listen. The dogs chasing each other with full abandon. Sometimes Tara laughs till she can’t breathe. Or the light hits the ivy on the wooden fence and it glows plum-red around the small rustling birds. Those moments feel like life. Still. Even though, right now, my entire day is devoted to planning my survival, arranging help and insurance and food…I’m here. Still. Even when invisible. Here.

Red Mexican cow creamer posed on a lighted window sill as if sniffing golden mums.

Hanging Out My Shingle – CRITIQUES!

Coffee shop table with treats, manuscripts, highlighters, and a journal

Coffee shop table with treats, manuscripts, highlighters, notecards, computer and a journal.

Picture Book Critiques!

I’m available for a limited number of picture book critiques. Interested? Read on…

Need Feedback?

I love helping people discover what their project “wants to become.” I taught writing and children’s literature for nearly two decades and use that experience to craft feedback that honors your vision and helps you move your work forward. I provide big-picture observations and questions, and line-level comments. I often address the creative process, possible mentor texts, methods for “seeing” a project or its structure and ideas of how to discover your next steps. I offer thorough, thoughtful, honest and encouraging feedback.

Best Fit

I’m a good fit for work that is lyrical, realistic, fantastical, humorous, conceptual, or about marginalized experiences. I can critique creative nonfiction and biographies (especially poetic NF), but my main expertise is fiction and lyrical concept books. I’m especially attuned to emotion, structure and language choices. I am not a good fit for meter and rhyme.

Details

Paid critiques are $250 and include:

  • Thorough summary and line comments
  • The option of a phone or video conversation
  • The option to submit a follow-up revision within a year for general overall impressions (verbal or written)
  • The option of a complete critique of a revision for $100 within a year of receiving feedback.

Critique Package

  • 3 full critiques of different picture book manuscripts for $650 (savings of $100). Manuscripts may be submitted within a year of hire.

Interested?

To see if I am available, CONTACT ME HERE. Include a Word document or link to your project(s). I typically turn around critiques in 1-2 weeks. I look forward to seeing your work!

Conversation with Military Families for Free Expression (MFFE)

Image of author C.S. Wild speaking, blue shirt reading, “For the love of God stop banning books”; light skin, dark blond shoulder-length hair, glasses

Inside MFFE’s Inaugural Virtual Gathering

On Sept. 9, 2025, I had the honor of joining other book professionals and Military Families for Free Expression (MFFE) for their first online event: “Inside MFFE’s Inaugural Virtual Gathering.”

FULL EVENT HERE (55:19)

The full conversation was so informative and moving – you won’t want to miss Philomena Polefrone explain the roots of this current censorship and Vicki Kwiatkowski’s stories as a military librarian of how young people in military settings are supporting each other and reading liberty. She also discussed using coded ways to support LGBTQIA+ students now that flags, pronouns and other forms of supportive speech have been banned in military settings. It was especially meaningful to join fellow military service and family members for this important conversation, which was equal parts heartbreaking and inspiring. Our assignment is clear.

From MFFE’s substack:

Event Highlights 

The MFFE gathering featured powerful perspectives from across the free expression and military family community:

  • Philomena Polefrone – Associate Director of the American Booksellers for Free Expression, sharing insights on national trends in censorship and how grassroots action makes a difference.
  • Vicki Kwiatkowski – Military spouse and former DODEA librarian, offering an inside look at how book challenges and restrictions affect students and educators.
  • Charlotte Sullivan Wild – Military spouse and author of a challenged book, speaking firsthand about what it means to have one’s work censored and why representation matters. (C.S. Wild excerpt (6:42))

Military members and families are uniquely and more instantly affected by government censorship of military libraries, schools, and speech – which is espeically frustrating given the many sacrifices our families make to serve our government. I’m very thankful for everyone supporting our young people and the newly-formed MFFE.

THANK YOU.

Unexpected Ripples of Mahmoud v. Taylor (Vaccines?!)

Two rainbow flags waving in front of the US Supreme Court building.

Two rainbow flags waving in front of the US Supreme Court building.

I’ve been reeling. We are starting to discover the real-life implications of Mahmoud v. Taylor – the Supreme Court case on school opt-outs that named Love, Violet and eight other LGBTQ+ picture books.  Some I expected and even warned about during the case. Others…I did not see coming. (What follows is from my social media post on Monday, Dec. 8, edited and updated, with new links.)

Does Mahmoud Even Apply to Crowd Images?

As I described in a previous post, a father in Lexington, Mass., has sued his school district, claiming that his child’s innocence was destroyed by two picture books, All Are Welcome (Penfold, Kaufman) and Familes, Families, Families (Lang, Lang).

His objection? All Are Welcome has a crowd illustration of a school fair that includes what might be a two-mom family among many families. That’s it. The other book shows many types of families, including those with lots of cousins, or no siblings, one mom, two dads, or grandparents. These are the kinds of families children already live in or observe around them.

This case is not strong. But if it does win, it could mean that educators must notify parents in advance of any portrayal of people they “don’t approve of” or don’t want to explain to their children, per his complaint. Think about that.

Consider the utterly impossible and immoral burden that this places on teachers who are supposed to 1) tell the truth and 2) support all students, not participate in erasing some because of the prejudices of others. The possibility of such extreme and unreasonable lawsuits could pressure educators to self-censor – though I hope schools choose to embrace and defend basic human decency. I hope communities support them in this.

Today this case is about erasing same-sex parents. Tomorrow it could be a white Christian parent demanding that teachers help them censor anyone of another religion or race — in every single book illustration. This goes far beyond religious liberty into violating children’s First Amendment rights and equal protection.

While extreme, many of the authors and illustrators involved in Mahmoud warned such applications were likely. But I never expected what happened next…

From LGBTQ+ Books to Vaccines?!

Monday morning, I woke to learn that SCOTUS has rejected a 2nd District case allowing New York schools to require vaccines for private AND PUBLIC school students without religious exemptions. (The vaccine requirement had been established after high numbers of religious exemptions had lead to a severe measles outbreak.) In their rejection, SCOTUS directed the 2nd District Court to look at Mahmoud – which allows parents to opt out of LGBTQ-inclusive picture books for religious reasons. They are suggesting that parents can send unvaccinated kids to any school if that choice is based on religion.

If this happens (which is still undecided), it will shift the danger and burden of this religious choice onto the whole public. Any family with a medically vulnerable person – an infant, immuno-compromised or elderly or severely ill person (like me), or someone going through chemo – those families would no longer have safe access to public schools because of the religious choices of others.

A family like mine would be forced to home school, even if they are already caring for a sick family member and don’t have anyone healthy available to do this. This feels like gross overreach again. People who make an ideological choice not to vaccinate should bear the responsibilities and danger of that choice themselves, and help to limit the danger they are imposing on others as much as possible. That includes finding a way to educate their children that doesn’t put other families at risk.

(It’s important to note that there are medical reasons some people cannot tolerate vaccines. If most of the public is vaccinated, that protects at-risk people. But that protection is fast disappearing. And now my picture book may be used to advance this danger – to put children at risk of catching preventable and series illnesses that can kill.)

In keeping with the current direction of this administration, the burden of these choices would be shoved on the already-ill and disabled and their families – in the name of religion. Just like the days before disability rights, families like mine would again be denied access to public spaces, including public schools. And this is being suggested on the basis of a SCOTUS case that demonized and mischaracterized LGBTQ+ people and our picture books, rather than discussing our lives and stories honestly.

Religious rights are sacred. My spouse is a military chaplain, who safeguards religious liberty and protects against religion-based oppression. Religious liberty must be protected. But “free exercise” may not cross into erasing and oppressing others, or imposing direct harm. That’s no one’s right. That’s discrimination.

My Dream…

What I long for is a country committed to valuing every single human as fully human, as worthy of equal representation, rights, and safety. Including people of color, LGBTQ+ people, disabled and ill people. That is not happening right now. We cannot rely on this government or these courts to protect people equally. This falls to us.

And. If we all keep showing up in our own communities, with library check-outs, with book purchases, by communicating with our local educators and school boards, by modeling kindness and respect to our children…I have to believe that one day, this ugly, hateful tide will turn. We can be better than this.

We must be better than this.

This dream is why I write. And why I won’t stop.

We must never stop.

***

(See also how SCOTUS this week turned down this book banning case from Llano, TX, denying First Amendment rights to libraries in TX, LA and MS. This is a massive blow and seems to be a complete denial of the First Amendment. Response from PEN America.)

Lexington Lawsuit Pushes Mahmoud to the Extreme. There’s Still HOPE.

Mahmoud v. Taylor in Action

It’s happening again. A father in Lexington, Massachusetts is suing a school district for reading two picture books about families to his kindergarten-aged child. He cites Mahmoud v. Taylor the case on opt-outs that named Love, Violet and other LGBTQ+ picture books.

He first asked that his child be opted out of DEI lessons, but this was rejected for vagueness. (Was the teacher supposed to censor everything that wasn’t about white, cis-het, able, Christian males? That is how some censors in the military interpreted such requests.)

Second, he asked for advance notice and opt-outs for his child for any lessons on sexual orientation and gender identity. However, his complaint reveals that his actual intent is that his child never see a same-sex couple depicted at school in a book or lesson.

The books he objected to include Families, Families, Families (Lang, Lang), which presents myriad family types and concludes, “…if you love each other, then you are family.”

The picture book Families, Families, Families, by Suzanne Lang, illustrated by Max Lang. Yellow striped background with various animal families lined up and leaning together.

The second book, All Are Welcome Here (Penfold, Kaufman), portrays children during a school day, from music class to lunch, and concluding with families visiting a school fair, during which families admire student projects.

The picture book All Are Welcome, by Alexandra Penfold, illustrated by Suzanne Kaufman. Various children and a father walking over a yellow crosswalk happily. Children are of different sizes, skin colors and hair types, with one wearing a hijab and one child on a scooter, others holding books or instrument cases.

Like the petitioners in Mahmoud, this father claims that these picture books contain “sexualized and ideological” content that has ruined the innocence of his child. He claims he has been forced to talk about different kinds of families with his child before he wanted to.

For reference, here is one of the offending “sexualized” illustrations.

(c) Suzanne Kaufman, All Are Welcome, Knopf, 2018. With a backdrop of colorful city buildings, a crossguard guides families and children of many races, religions, and abilities over a crosswalk.

(c) Suzanne Kaufman, All Are Welcome, Knopf, 2018. With a backdrop of colorful city buildings, a smiling crossing guard guides families and children of many races, body types, and abilities over a crosswalk.

Wait. You don’t see the problem? Didn’t you notice the pregnant mom in blue, holding her child’s hand? The problem still isn’t clear? Maybe this will help…

(c) Suzanne Kaufman, All Are Welcome, Knopf, 2018. With a backdrop of flags from around the world, a variety of families enjoy a school fair with their children, with people of many ethnicities, religions, abilities, and family types visible.

(c) Suzanne Kaufman, All Are Welcome, Knopf, 2018. With a backdrop of flags from around the world, a variety of families enjoy a school fair with their children, with people of many ethnicities, religions, abilities, and family types visible.

Did you spot the mom in blue in the upper right corner of this crowded scene? If you look really closely, no – closer, there. See? She appears to have a female partner, though this is not clarified in the text, and the other woman could also be a sister or friend or aunt. (I personally hope it’s her partner because, when I was young, children’s books never included families like the kind I would one day have.) I’ve shared less than half of this spread, so a child in a class story time would have to really pay attention to these tiny figures to catch that “sexualized” content.

When people rail against “pornographic” picture books, when they harass and threaten educators and librarians, when they send book creators hate mail or threats, this is what they are calling sexually explicit content.

You don’t see any sex?

(Long sigh.)

They don’t see fellow humans.

Unethical Burdens on Educators

(c) Charlene Chua, Love, Violet, FSG 2022. Image of a classroom with kid art and diverse children giving out valentines and holding baskets. A teacher, with short brown hair, a tie, white shirt and gray pants, has arms out spread, happily directing the students.

What could this Lexington case mean for the future application of Mahmoud? I hope – nothing. Because the “ask” is so extreme and overtly discriminatory. But…if it gains traction…

This Lexington suit could suggest there are few limits on individual parental rights, even when they may infringe on the rights of their own children or other children, other families, or educators.

The Boston Globe: Article headline and image of protestors with rainbow umbrellas and signs supporting inclusive education in front of the Supreme Court building. Heading: Lexington lawsuit tests Supreme Court’s ruling on LGBTQ+ lessons By Katie Muchnick Globe Correspondent, Updated November 13, 2025, 8:46 p.m. Picture caption: Protesters in support of LGBTQ+ rights and against book bans demonstrated outside the Supreme Court on April 22 during the case of Mahmoud v. Taylor. Anna Moneymaker/Getty.

This Lexington father expected teachers to comb through in advance every picture book, lesson, and video…including crowd scenes…and notify him of any portrayals that might be LGBTQ+ people.

As a former educator, my head spins. When would one have time to teach or plan with such an unreasonable task?

Worse, it is morally offensive. This lawsuit asks educators to help parents lie to children and erase an entire people group. For those who “disapprove” of LGBTQ+ people’s existence, who don’t believe LGBTQ+ people are were born this way, it is not a choice – maybe then, such censorship seems “reasonable.”

But even then, this principle endangers religion. It would open the door for any parent to justify erasing anyone – or suing schools when they fail to participate in crafting a uniquely segregated curriculum for any given child. If this case succeeds, Christian parents could demand opt-outs from images of hijabs or yarmulkes; white parents could demand no Black or Brown representation. This is an assault on what school is for – and what our Declaration of Independence is supposed to stand for.

Black italic text on white: "We hold these truthes to be sef-evident, that all men are created equal, that they are endowed by their Creator with certain unalienable Rights, that among these are these are Life, LIberty and the pursuit of Happiness." From the Declaration of Independence.

This isn’t mere speculation. Although Mahmoud only addressed LGBTQ+ picture books, the first report on opt-out requests in Montgomery County, Maryland (where Mahmoud originated), shows that parents also censored books about Indigenous and Black experiences, and social justice. Mahmoud is immediately being used to hide historically marginalized people of every kind.

An unchecked application of Mahmoud goes far beyond the free exercise of religion. It insists on state-sponsored bigotry.

How can we raise well-educated children able to get along in the classroom and the world, if parents won’t let children learn about anyone unlike themselves? Including their own classmates? What does this do to children witnessing opt-outs? What about children’s constitutional rights to free speech and equal protection? What about LGBTQ+ children, whose parents censor LGBTQ+ content? Neither censorship nor access to information can change anyone’s identity, only how prepared children are to interact with respect.

So many of today’s parents and grandparents grew up in censored communities. So many of us know (from both sides) the harm censorship and prejudice inflicts, the quiet bias it embeds in hearts and minds – whether the harmful ideas are about others or oneself.

Mahmoud hurts children.

By definition, Mahmoud is an anti-education decision.

In the months to come, we will learn just how far people will use it to justify harm toward children, truth, and public schools. And how far each of us will go to defend the rights and needs of children in public schools, as well as their librarians and educators.

What Can We Do?

Never Give Up

6. Top banner with covers of picture books. Footer, pink to yellow with black text: "Love can still win! [heart] Charlotte xoxo" A soft heart frames the word "love." The center image is of the Supreme Court building at twilight, with light inside the building, rainbow and stars above it, with colorful characters from all the books on the steps. A joyful scene.

Top banner with the covers of the picture books named in Mahmoud v. Taylor. Footer fades pink to yellow with black text: “Love can still win! [heart] Charlotte xoxo” A soft heart frames the word “love.” Center image: (c) Julie McLaughlin 2025, used with permission. The Supreme Court building at twilight, with light inside the building, rainbow and stars above it, with colorful characters from all the Mahmoud books on the steps. A joyful scene.

Lawsuits like this one are a true threat to schools and libraries and educators. The pressure must feel overwhelming. Every week we learn of new ways the three branches of our government are cutting up the Constitution and eating it for breakfast – and consistently in ways that promote hierarchies of race, gender, religion, and wealth (Heather Cox Richardson 28:45 – 34:30). We are caught in a conflict between those who reject this country’s founding idea of equality and those who believe all humans are born equal, deserving of life and liberty.

The foundational principles of this nation and of education are under direct attack, through Mahmoud and so many new rules, laws, and court decisions. But the Constitution is on our side. Justice and morality are on our side. Our country is at an inflection point when we could succumb to fascism – or enough people can resist to protect each other and liberty. Many people reject domination and oppression of over half of our society.

To educators and librarians, thank you for your hard, endless work. Thank you for the courage and love you show every time you show up for all your students and patrons, and for your core values. You are our heroes and you have masses, masses of people behind you, ready to advocate for your safety and rights.

Community members, educators and librarians need our vocal (and written) support now more than ever.

(Here’s an example from TN of why public support is so important, from author and friend Christina Soontornvat.)

One of the best things we can do is to write positive notes to librarians, teachers, school boards, and local papers about what their work and inclusive education and books mean to your family. We can show up. Book banners are loud. Defenders of liberty and children can be, too. Written support provides essential counter evidence when one person or a tiny handful of people try to hijack a curriculum or erase and oppress a marginalized group of people, or intimidate and threaten librarians and educators. Every one of our voices matters.

We can support and follow the organizations advocating for reading freedom (Authors Against Book Bans, PEN America, EveryLibrary, Unite Against Book Bans).

We can pay attention to local and state politics; vote and contact decision makers. We can advocate for free and safe schools and libraries even if we don’t have children. Most important, no matter what atrocities horrify us, we can do what loving, freedom-minded adults have always done: support the  children in our lives by teaching and modeling respect, equality, and love. The world will never be fair or perfect. But we can young people find the just-right books and information, we can equip them to see through lies and prejudice, we can prepare them to help create the world of our dreams.

Victory Despite Defeats

(c) Mary Lundquist, The Amazing Idea of You, 2019. Two curved vines emanate from an apple seed to frame an apple tree, full of fruit, some in the grass.

This moment requires a long view. We live in a moment of cognitive dissonance. Yes, checks and balances are cracking. The freedoms promised the founding documents of the US are being trampled. Democracy is crumbling and already giving way to fascism. And yet…

We who love liberty and equality have power. Voices. And, strangely, we also live in a state of victory, of progress. For all these losses, we are not lost.

What do I mean? That father in the Lexington case seeks to obliterate my family and my book. I grew up in a world like that, where people like me were hidden or ridiculed and punished. He wants to lie to his child and pretend that LGBTQ+ people are never born, don’t have families or love, or thrive.

But no petty lawsuit can force me back into the closet. It’s impossible! My marriage is not only real, it has been legally recognized since 2014. And if that protection vanishes, my marriage won’t. There are photos! Financial records. So many witnesses: family, friends, former students and readers and every stranger we pass. Like so many LGBTQ+ people, I live in honesty, out loud, in a way I could not have dreamed of in the 1980s. I couldn’t have pictured it because I had no picture books like Love, Violet, no commercials or movies with people like me. That day is done.

(c) Charlene Chua, Stonewall Book Award Acceptance Speech, 2023. With blue background fading to white, a line of diverse children hold hands, with different skin and hair colors and types (including blue hair), gender expressions, abilities and body shapes (including a little person and one in a wheelchair), and hobbies (including a soccer player, ballet dancer, punk rocker) and religions (child in a hijab). Above their heads are flags for many LGBTQIAP+ identities.

Even if this lawsuit succeeds – does it? The harm will be profound. Absolutely. It is already hurting children, educators, librarians, and book creators. But that father will never get what he really wants: to erase real people. But we are everywhere and we are visible. While our soicety is not yet equal or safe, we are living the victory of visibility. He can’t take that away.

I need to remember this.

And that improvements in visibility, understanding, and acceptance have grown dramatically for people of color, women, those of and minority religions and ethnicities, and with disabilities, too. This violent backlash is a reaction to our present victories. And while some progress is being dismanted, I believe it can never fully be undone – if we contine creating this better world together. Little by little. Child by child, action by action, relationship by relationship.

I need to remember this.

The horror is real – and requires our action. (My soul rips, wails at so much harm.) And – the progress is real. May it bring us healing and hope for the work before us.

We can do this. We can make real – or keep striving toward – that foundational idea that every one of us is born equal and worthy of life, liberty, and the pursuit of joy.

Hold fast, friends. For children, for democracy, for everyone: Hold fast.

CSW

Baby born the same weeked as Love, Violet looks at the final spread where Mira and Violet are running through the snow together, holding hands. The baby has light skin, a red outfit and white socks.

Baby born the same weeked as Love, Violet looks at the final spread where Mira and Violet are running through the snow together, holding hands.